The practice of issuing founder shares at Nominal Value (or Par Value, often £0.01 or £0.0001 per share) at the time of company incorporation is standard procedure in the UK. From a Capital Gains Tax (CGT) perspective, this is strategically advantageous as it establishes a very low Base Cost for future CGT calculations upon a lucrative company exit. However, this practice carries a significant and immediate tax risk under UK law (specifically the Employment Related Securities (ERS) legislation) if the shares are deemed to have a higher Actual Market Value (AMV) than the price paid.
The core implication is that the difference between the shares’ AMV and the price paid by the founder is treated by HMRC as a taxable discount, known as a ‘benefit in kind’ or ’employment income’. This discount is immediately subject to Income Tax and potentially National Insurance Contributions (NIC), which must be reported via the ERS system. The key, therefore, is not to avoid the low price, but to manage the valuation and compliance.
The ERS Regime and the Taxable Discount
The Employment Related Securities (ERS) rules (contained in Part 7 of the Income Tax Earnings and Pensions Act 2003) are designed to ensure that any value received by an employee or director in the form of shares, by reason of their employment or office, is taxed. Since a founder is almost always an employee or director, their shares fall under this regime.
The Immediate Income Tax Charge
The tax risk crystallises on the day the founder subscribes for their shares:
Taxable Event: AMV vs Price Paid
If the Actual Market Value (AMV) of the shares on the issue date exceeds the Nominal Value paid by the founder, the difference is considered an immediate taxable gain. The founder is liable to pay Income Tax on this discount at their marginal rate (up to 45%).
For a newly incorporated, pre-revenue company where no investors have yet put in capital, the AMV is often defensibly equal to the Nominal Value or a very small premium, meaning the immediate tax charge is negligible. However, if the shares are issued after significant intellectual property has been created, or after a third-party investment round that establishes a high valuation, the AMV will be significantly higher, and the founder will face a substantial, immediate tax bill.
The PAYE and NIC Complication
If the shares are considered a Readily Convertible Asset (RCA) (which typically occurs if there is a known buyer or exit event on the near horizon), the employing company is obligated to operate PAYE and collect the Income Tax, plus pay the associated Employer NIC, which currently stands at 13.8%. This unexpected and potentially large liability for the company can severely impact working capital.
Restricted Shares and the Power of the Section 431 Election
Founder shares are almost always considered restricted securities because the company’s Articles of Association and Shareholders’ Agreement typically contain restrictions on transfer, good leaver/bad leaver clauses, or pre-emption rights.
The UMV vs AMV Dilemma
- Actual Market Value (AMV): The value of the shares taking into account all legal restrictions.
- Unrestricted Market Value (UMV): The theoretical value of the shares ignoring all legal restrictions.
- Without protective action, HMRC can argue that future growth in the shares’ value (when restrictions are lifted, varied, or at the point of sale) should be taxed as Income Tax, based on the growth proportionate to the discount between the AMV and the UMV at the date of acquisition.
The Critical Section 431 Election
To prevent this ongoing Income Tax risk, the founder (employee) and the company (employer) must jointly sign a Section 431 Election (under ITEPA 2003). This election:
- Treats all future growth as Capital Gains (taxable at the lower CGT rates, potentially 10% with BADR).
- Requires the founder to pay Income Tax upfront on the full discount between the UMV and the price paid at the time of issue.
- This election is almost always beneficial, particularly when shares are issued at Nominal Value at incorporation, as the AMV and UMV are close to zero, meaning the immediate Income Tax liability is negligible, and the founder secures the lower CGT rate on all subsequent growth. The election must be made within 14 days of the share acquisition.
Q&A: Nominal Value and Tax Planning
What is the key difference between AMV and UMV?
Answer: AMV is the value of the shares as they actually stand, including all restrictions that affect their saleability or rights (e.g., compulsory transfer clauses, good/bad leaver provisions). UMV is the value of those shares if the restrictions were ignored. Because restrictions typically reduce value, AMV is often lower than UMV. This difference is what HMRC targets for future Income Tax charges unless a Section 431 Election is filed.
When should the Section 431 Election be made?
Answer: The Section 431 Election must be made no later than 14 days after the date the shares were acquired. Missing this strict deadline irrevocably exposes the founder to potential future Income Tax charges on the disposal of their shares. Best practice is to prepare and sign the election documents concurrently with the company’s incorporation.
What happens if a founder issues shares to themselves after the first investment round?
Answer: Issuing shares to a founder after an external investment round is extremely dangerous from a tax perspective. The investment round establishes a clear, high Actual Market Value (AMV). If the founder then issues shares to themselves at Nominal Value, the discount (the difference between the high AMV and the low price paid) is immediately taxable as Income Tax and subject to PAYE and Employer NIC, as the shares are highly likely to be considered a Readily Convertible Asset (RCA). This typically leads to a significant and immediate PAYE tax bill for the founder and the company.
AZL Accounting: Securing Base Cost and CGT Efficiency
For early-stage startups, the initial share issuance is a critical Statutory Compliance matter that determines future tax liabilities. AZL, our expert accounting firm in England and Wales, provides essential services to mitigate the initial Income Tax risk while securing the long-term low Base Cost for CGT efficiency.
Valuation Audit and AMV Assessment
AZL conducts a pre-issue Valuation Audit to establish a defensible Actual Market Value (AMV) for the founder shares. When issuing shares at Nominal Value, we document the lack of value creation immediately after incorporation (pre-revenue, pre-IP) to provide an audit trail for HMRC should the low valuation ever be queried. This ensures the immediate Income Tax liability remains negligible.
Section 431 Election Execution and ERS Compliance
We manage the preparation and timely execution of the Section 431 Election and the subsequent mandatory registration of the share arrangement on the HMRC ERS system. By strictly adhering to the 14-day deadline, AZL ensures the founder’s entire future gain is taxed as Capital Gains and not Income Tax, providing certainty and significant long-term tax savings. This ongoing Statutory Compliance is vital, as HMRC requires annual ERS returns to be filed for all registered schemes.
Capital Gains Planning and Base Cost Management
The low Nominal Value becomes the founder’s Base Cost for CGT purposes. AZL confirms the correct Base Cost calculation and ensures the founder meets all 24-month holding requirements for Business Asset Disposal Relief (BADR). Our forward-looking approach ensures that the low initial cost translates into the maximum possible CGT saving at the point of exit.
Integrated Payroll and Tax Efficiency
AZL’s expertise ensures that the founder’s share acquisition does not inadvertently trigger unexpected PAYE or NIC liabilities for the company. We integrate ERS reporting with our comprehensive payroll and bookkeeping services, providing a single, compliant financial framework that supports the company’s structure from incorporation through to exit.
Industry Benefit: AZL’s Role in Founder Wealth Creation
For early-stage UK startups, AZL’s service is an investment in future wealth. Issuing founder shares at Nominal Value is a calculated risk, but a necessary step for CGT efficiency. By mastering the intricate rules of HMRC ERS, AZL enables founders to:
- Legally Lock-in Low CGT: Securing the Section 431 Election is the financial firewall that ensures 90% of the eventual gain is taxed at the lower Capital Gains rate.
- Avoid Immediate Tax Bills: Our precise compliance and valuation advice prevents the founder and company from facing crippling, unexpected Income Tax and NIC charges.
- Ensure Compliance: We manage the mandatory HMRC filings, allowing founders to focus entirely on growth while knowing their personal tax position is fully protected under UK law.